Petco’s Top Rated Pet Toys

Photo of author
Updated On

I Love Veterinary blog is reader-supported, and we may earn a commission from products purchased through links on this page, at no additional cost to you. Learn more About Us and our Product Review Process >

Spoiling Your Pets With Toys

As a pet parent, it is critical to understand that your pet reaps excellent physical exercise benefits. Furthermore, your pet benefits intellectually when you interact with it. Pet toys are a perfect way to offer your pet mental stimulation and give you a chance to spend time with them. 

There are numerous pet toys available on the market. In this post, you will discover Petco’s top-rated pet toys you can choose from. Read on to find out more.

Petco’s Top Rated Pet Toys

15. Nerf Tough Infinity Tug Dog Toy

Petco’s Nerf Dog toys are specially designed to make them durable and functional. They also come in various shapes and sizes to suit different dogs’ needs.

Why we like it

  • It is fully stuffed.
  • It is a blend of nylon and rubber.
  • It comes in bright colors for visibility.

Customer reviews

Customers are generally happy with the product. They also claim the pets loved it a lot.

14. Kong Puppy Goodie Bone w/Rope Assorted Toy, X-Small

This is a great toy if your puppy loves chew sessions. It is also excellent for training your pup good chewing behavior and eases aching teeth and gums. Your pup will also have an extra chewing choice with the all-cotton rope.

Why we like it

  • It is durable.
  • The cotton rope helps to clean your pup’s teeth as it learns good chewing behavior.
  • It comes in assorted colors.

Customer Reviews

Many customers who bought this product are satisfied with it. Most love that it is designed to allow them to bond with their toys.

13. Leaps & Bounds Small Wildlife Mallard Plush Toy

This toy will help your pet have a great time as it shakes and chews. It will also allow you to bond with your pet as you engage it in a game of chase.

Why we like it

  • It keeps your pet healthy.
  • Available in various sizes.
  • Spot Clean.

Customer Reviews

Customers who bought this toy for their pets are happy with it. Their pets also love it, and it gives the pet parents a chance to play with their pets.

12. DC Comics Justice League Batman Double Knot Rope Dog Toy

This toy is fully equipped to fascinate your chewy pup. It also comes with a crinkle fabric that will make your pet yearn for a game of tug-of-war.

Why we like it

  • The crinkle lining on the wings will attract your pup’s attention.
  • The toy’s soft rope will massage your pet’s gums and teeth as it chews.
  • The plush bat and double-knitted rope are durable.

Customer Reviews

Customers in their reviews claim that they love this toy more because it does not squeak.

11. Kong Dangle Feet Teaser Feather Assorted Cat Toy

The Kong Feather Teaser is expertly designed for interactive play. Each toy will offer your pet extra stimulation because of the Kong Premium North American Catnip. Your cat will be tempted to catch the toy because of the crinkle sound and brightly colored feathers.

Why we like it

  • It is designed for interactive play.
  • Produces a crinkle sound to motivate your pet to play.
  • It comes with the premium catnip that gives your pet extra stimulation.

Customer Reviews

Most customers that already bought the toy recommend it to other pet parents. In their reviews, they claim that the toy keeps their pets engaged.

10. Multipet Black Bear Dog Toy

This 24-inch lovely Jumbo Bear offers your dog lots of fun. It is soft, plush, and has a squeaker making it more fun for your pet.

Why we like it:

  • It comes with a squeaker for extra fun.
  • Its size is ideal for your dog to play with.
  • It is easy for your dog to fetch, toss and snuggle.

Customer Reviews

Customers claim in their reviews that this toy would be worth your while. Those that have it claim their pets love it a lot. 

9. Leaps & Bounds Hooked on You Fish Kitten Scratcher Toys, Small

This is the perfect toy to help your pet tickle their desire to scratch. The toy is made of thick canvas with an excellent texture that can help your kitten grow its instincts.

Why we like it

  • It comes with a unique texture that engages your kitten.
  • It also has a corded loop attachment for catnip.
  • The thick canvas is excellent to help your kitten develop its instinct to scratch.

Customer Reviews

Customers express their love for this toy in their reviews. They particularly love it because it is safe.

8. Pestages Green Buggin Out Puzzle & Play Interactive Cat Treat Toy

Your cat will love to bat the pegs and swivel as it tries to uncover the hidden treat compartments. What’s more, you can adjust the puzzle’s level of difficulty if your pet is a beginner. This toy will help your cat to work on their hunting and foraging nature.

Why we like it

  • It helps to stimulate your cat’s intrinsic foraging nature.
  • You can use the toy to feed your cat.
  • It is made of food-safe materials.

Customer Reviews

Customers in their reviews have praised this toy. It is excellent as it keeps the cat busy with exciting puzzles. All the reviewers recommend the product to other pet owners.

7. Pusheen Mermaid Crinkle Plush Cat Toy, Pack of 2

Treat your pet with a gorgeous Pusheen Mermaid Plush toy. The toy is soft and lasts long but with a crunch layer on the inside to motivate play.

Why we like it

  • The toy is soft and durable.
  • It has a crunchy layer to stimulate play.
  • It features Pusheen, Mermaid shapes, and designs.

Customer Reviews

Customers in their review state that the toy is good looking and comes in perfect sizes. It is a great toy!

6. Marvel Spider-Man Flattie Dog Toy

This toy comes with exciting noises and textures that will help keep your pet on its toes. Your dog will love the way the toy crinkles and squeaks instigating its senses.

Why we love it

  • The toy squeaks to encourage your pet to play.
  • The body is crinkle-lined to offer another engaging sound.
  • It is good looking with the Spider-Man lush head.

Customer Reviews

According to customer reviews, this toy is best for younger pups.

5. Bark Super Chewer Comet Dog Toy, Medium

BARK Super Chewer Comet Dog Toy, Petco's Top Rated Pet Toys - I Love Veteirnary
Check price on Petco

If your dog loves a challenge, it will love playing with this excellent rubber dog toy. The dog toy is made of natural rubber and will ensure long-lasting rounds of fetch. It has a super bounce that will keep your dog chasing and chewing.

Why we love it

  • It is a strong-jaw squeaker.
  • It is made of natural rubber.
  • It has a super bounce that keeps the dog active.

Customer Reviews

Most customers highly recommend this toy in their reviews. The toy keeps your pet actively engaged and lasts longer compared to other balls.

4. Leaps & Bounds Playful by Nature Pounce & Play Pond Mega Pack Cat Toys

This toy pack comes with six intentionally designed toys that will ensure your pet is never bored. They are made from familiar materials to make them your pet’s favorite.

Why we love it

  • The toys are expertly designed to facilitate interactive and independent play.
  • It is ideal for playful pets.
  • The toys are made of standard materials.  

Customer Reviews

Customer reviews reveal that the toy pack meets its purpose. It is also critical that pets love the toys.

3. Petlinks Tipsy Turtle Cat Toy, Small

This is the go-to toy for your cat. It is a refillable catnip cat toy that comes in different colors. It is also safe as it is made of chemical-free materials.

Why We Love it

  • This toy is made without pesticides or chemicals.
  • It comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.
  • It also comes in various colors.

Customer Reviews

The toy comes highly recommended by the pet parents who bought it. They love that it comes with a lot of room for catnip.

2. Outward Hound Tornado Puzzle Dog Toy, Large

This toy would be an ideal choice for training dogs. It contains dog games and puzzles, which are a great way of entertaining and engaging your furry friend. The games are appropriate for dogs of different ages.

Why We love it

  • It comes in different levels to cater to dogs at different training levels.
  • The toy design keeps your dog engaged in a fun yet challenging way.
  • It is ideal for training dogs.

Customer Reviews

This toy has received numerous positive reviews. The customers state that the toy is perfect for their pets.

1. Nylabone Holiday Puppy Red Green White Teething Key Toys

This is an ideal toy for teething pups. It is made from soft, puppy-friendly material that encourages your pup to have positive chewing habits. The bristles rise during chewing to help clean your pet’s teeth.

Why we love it

  • It cleans your pup’s teeth and removes tartar.
  • It discourages destructive chewing.
  • It comes in bacon flavor.

Customer Reviews

Customers claim in their reviews that the toy is perfect for their pets.

Summary: Our Favorite Product

If you have read all the toy reviews in this guide, you must have found a favorite. Our favorite product is the Nylabone Holiday Puppy Red Green White Teething Key Toys. We love this toy because:

  • It is not for entertainment only. It also cleans its teeth and removes tartar.
  • If your pup plays with this toy from a young age, it will not have destructive chewing behavior.
  • It also comes in a bacon flavor, making it attractive to the pet.

Bear in mind that some of the links in this article are affiliate links and if you go through them to make a purchase we will earn a commission. We promote and their products because of their quality and not because of the commission. The decision is yours, and whether or not you decide to buy something is completely up to you.

Sharing is caring!

Photo of author


Project dedicated to support and help to improve Veterinary Medicine. Sharing information and raising discussions in the veterinary community.