8 Best Bully Sticks for Dogs

I Love Veterinary blog is reader-supported, and we may earn a commission from products purchased through links on this page, at no additional cost to you. Learn more About Us and our Product Review Process >

Table of Content show

Explore the best bully sticks for dogs in our comprehensive review, featuring expert insights and top brands.

What are Bully Sticks Made of?

Bully sticks are made from the penis or pizzle of a bull. They undergo a rigorous cleaning process, then slow-roasting and drying to ensure safety and tastiness. To select the best quality bully sticks, focus on sourcing. 

High-quality products typically come from grass-fed, hormone-free bulls, providing maximum nutritional benefits and minimal health risks for your dog. Always prioritize transparency about the manufacturing process when choosing these chew treats.

Are Bully Sticks Good for Dogs?

Absolutely, the best bully sticks for dogs offer numerous health benefits. They serve as a high-protein, low-fat snack, promoting dental health by reducing plaque and tartar. However, like any dog treats, dog bully sticks should be given in moderation and always under supervision. 

A bully stick’s hardness can pose a choking hazard or cause blockages if swallowed in large pieces. Select the appropriate size and strength for your dog’s breed and chewing habits.

ILVs Hands-Down Favorite Bully Stick

As dog lovers aim to find the best dog bully sticks, Brutus & Barnaby’s Bully Sticks for Dogs often tops the list. The best rated bully sticks combine safety, quality, and enjoyment, a balance this product maintains superbly.

These bully sticks are 100% natural, made from grass-fed, free-range bulls, thereby ensuring optimal nutrition and minimal risk. Furthermore, they undergo a meticulous preparation process that guarantees a safe, enjoyable, and low-odor chew treat.

What sets Brutus & Barnaby apart is their commitment to pet safety and customer satisfaction. Each stick is thoroughly inspected for size consistency, ensuring it suits your dog’s breed and chewing strength. 

Plus, they offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee, promising a full refund if the product does not meet your standards. This dedication to quality makes their bully sticks the top choice for many pet owners.

Other Bully Stick Brands at a Glance

  1. Brutus & Barnaby’s Bully Sticks for Dogs –  Best Overall
  2. Natural Farm Odor-Free Braided Bully Sticks Best for Long-Lasting Chewing
  3. Jack & Pup Premium Grade Odor-Free Bully Sticks Dog Treats Best Odor-Free Bully Sticks
  4. Pawstruck Bully Stick Springs for Dogs Best Free-Range Bully Sticks
  5. Barkworthies Odor-Free 6-inch Bully Sticks Best for Dental Health
  6. Sancho & Lola's Bully Sticks for Dogs Best One-Ingredient Bully Sticks
  7. Downtown Pet Supply USA Sourced 12", 10 Pack Bully Sticks for Large Dogs, Regular - Rawhide Free Dog Chews Long Lasting and Non-Splintering - Single Ingredient, Low Odor Bully Sticks for Medium Dogs Best Bully Sticks for Large Dogs
  8. Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks for Dogs - Premium Natural Beef Dental Bones Best for Small Dogs and Puppies

Our Best Bully Sticks Reviews Below

(Using your round-up review guidelines, write about the following products and cover ALL the following topics under each. Start with the top pick first:

Brutus & Barnaby’s Bully Sticks for Dogs  –  Best Overall

Amazon’s Choice in Bully Stick Dog Treats by Brutus & Barnaby

Brand: Brutus & Barnaby

Lifestage: All

Item Form: Stick

Size/s:

  • 12-inch sticks (30 centimeters)  in packs of 3, 5 and 10
  • 5-inch sticks (12 centimeters) in packs of 8 ounces (226 grams) and 1 pound (453 grams)
  • 6-inch sticks (15 centimeters) in packs of 50 or 8 ounces (226 grams)
  • Bites – 1 pound (453 grams) 
  • Bites – 2 pounds (907 grams) 
  • Bites – 5 pounds (2.26 kilograms)
  • Skinny sticks – 1 pound (453 grams) 
  • Skinny sticks – 8 ounces (226 grams)

Brutus & Barnaby offers the best rated bully sticks on the market, sourced from grass-fed, free-range cattle. These all-natural bully sticks are not bleached, providing a healthier alternative to typical dog treats. 

Available in various lengths, they’re suitable for dogs of all sizes and are fully digestible. Chewing on these bully sticks will not only help scrape away tartar but also expend your dog’s energy. 

With minimal odor and a firm commitment to quality, Brutus & Barnaby promises a snack your dog will love.

What We LikedWhat We Don’t Like
All-natural ingredients, free from chemicalsSome dogs may prefer a stronger odor for their chews
Fully digestible, eliminating concerns of splintering or crumbling piecesMore expensive compared to less natural, lower-quality options
Promote oral health by helping scrape away tartar
Minimal odor compared to other treats
Sourced from grass-fed, free-range cattle without added hormones.
Suitable for all canines, including teething puppies

Natural Farm Odor-Free Braided Bully Sticks – Best for Long-Lasting Chewing

Brand: Natural Farm

Flavor: Beef

Lifestage: All

Item Form: Stick

Recommended Uses:

  • Active
  • Behavior
  • Indoor
  • Joints
  • Teeth

Size/s:

  • 12-inch (30 centimeters) pack containing 12 sticks
  • 6-inch (15 centimeters) pack containing 5 sticks

Natural Farm Odor-Free Braided Bully Sticks  are an excellent dog treat made from 100% natural beef skin of free-range, grass-fed cattle. These chews are rich in natural collagen and a great alternative to traditional rawhide. 

They provide additional chew time and help stimulate jaw muscles, reducing plaque and tartar build-up. The company’s commitment to health extends to ensuring all products are hormone-free, chemical-free, and antibiotic-free. 

Furthermore, they believe that bully sticks are good for dogs, serving as a fantastic treat for dogs of all sizes and shapes.

What We LikedWhat We Don’t Like
Free of preservatives, chemicals, and additivesSome dogs might not enjoy the texture of collagen as much as other types of chews
A potent natural source of collagen promoting healthier skin, coats, and jointsMore expensive than lower-quality, non-collagen-based chews
Provides longer chewing time compared to standard bully sticks, supporting dental healthVigilant supervision is required during chewing to avoid choking hazards
A commitment to health and safety means all products are hormone-free, chemical-free, and antibiotic-free
Environmentally friendly packaging, with 51% of it made from renewable sugar cane

Jack & Pup Premium Grade Odor-Free Bully Sticks Dog Treats – Best Odor-Free Bully Sticks

Brand: Jack & Pup

Flavor: Beef

Lifestage: All

Item Form: Stick

Recommended Uses: Weight control

Size: 6-inch (15 centimeters) pack of 5

Jack & Pup Premium Grade Odor-Free Bully Sticks Dog Treats  are a top-quality treat choice that significantly contributes to the health and well-being of your pet. Sourced from grass-fed, free-range cattle, these bully sticks contain no added hormones or antibiotics, ensuring a healthy, protein-rich chew for your dog. 

Their consistent thickness makes them a long-lasting treat, and they are processed in a USDA Human Grade Certified and Inspected facility, giving you peace of mind about your pet’s snack. 

Notably, these bully sticks help maintain your dog’s oral health by removing tartar build-up and plaque, while their natural beef flavor makes them a treat your pet will love. Indeed, these bully sticks are suitable for dogs in several ways.

What We LikedWhat We Don’t Like
Enhances oral health by removing tartar build-up and plaqueThese are premium products, so they might be more expensive than other bully sticks
Sourced from grass-fed, free-range cattle without any added hormones or antibioticsTheir extra thickness may not be suitable for smaller dogs or puppies
Manufacturer in a USDA Human Grade Certified and Inspected facility, ensuring safetyNeed to ensure the bully stick does not splinter, requiring constant supervision
Fully digestible and safe with no added additives or artificial ingredients

Pawstruck Bully Stick Springs for Dogs  – Best Free-Range Bully Sticks

Amazon’s Choice in Bully Stick Dog Treats by Pawstruck

Brand: Pawstruck

Flavor: Beef

Lifestage: All

Item Form: Spring

Recommended Uses:

  • Behavior
  • Coat
  • Joints
  • Skin
  • Teeth

Size/s:

  • 3-count (pack of 1)
  • 10-count (pack of 1)
  • 25-count (pack of 1)
  • 50-count (pack of 1)
  • 100-count (pack of 1)
  • 250-count (pack of 1)

Pawstruck Bully Sticks  offer a unique, equitable solution to the common concern of inconsistent sizing in bully sticks. By selling their product by weight, Pawstruck ensures you receive a fair deal regardless of individual stick size. 

This benefits more sticks in a bag if they’re smaller. These bully sticks are derived from grass-fed, free-range cattle in South America, guaranteeing high-quality, natural chew treats without any additives or artificial chemicals. 

Furthermore, they offer a variety of formats beyond traditional sticks, including bites, rings, and braids.

What We LikedWhat We Don’t Like
Sold by weight, ensuring fair value regardless of stick sizeInconsistent size may not be ideal for pet owners who need specific sizes for their dogs
Sourced from grass-fed, free-range South American cattle, promoting qualityWhile being sold by weight can be a benefit, it might also lead to receiving smaller sticks, which may not last as long for larger dogs
Free of additives and artificial chemicals, enhancing their health benefitsSourcing from South America could raise concerns about carbon footprint due to shipping distances for some eco-conscious customers
Available in a variety of formats (sticks, bites, rings, braids) for diverse preferences

Barkworthies Odor-Free 6-inch Bully Sticks – Best for Dental Health

Brand: Barkworthies

Flavor: Beef

Item Form: Stick

Recommended Uses: 

  • Oral health
  • Nutrition

Size/s:

  • 6-inch (15 centimeters) pack of 5
  • 12-inch (30 centimeters) pack of 3
  • 12-inch (30 centimeters) pack of 5

Barkworthies presents premium, long-lasting chews designed to satisfy even the most eager chewers. Known for being highly digestible, these odor-free bully sticks provide a natural and safe alternative to rawhide that your dogs can enjoy all day. 

The chews adhere to high-quality standards with no artificial preservatives, mirroring nature’s simplicity for your dog’s health. The single-ingredient chews come from responsibly sourced, free-range, grass-fed beef, ensuring protein-rich nutrition. 

Furthermore, Barkworthies considers your dog’s dental health, offering chews that promote a healthy smile while tasting great.

What We LikedWhat We Don’t Like
Long-lasting chews suitable for medium-strength chewersMay not be suitable for highly vigorous chewers due to medium strength
Highly digestible and safe for all dogsThe chewing time varies significantly depending on the dog’s breed and enthusiasm
No artificial preservatives, promoting a natural and healthy choiceSingle-ingredient chews might lack variety for dogs who prefer diverse flavors
Made from free-range, grass-fed beef, ensuring high-quality protein
Promotes dental health, making them beneficial beyond just a chew treat

Sancho & Lola's Bully Sticks for Dogs  – Best One-Ingredient Bully Sticks

Brand: Sancho & Lola’s Closet

Flavor: Beef 

Item Form: Stick

Size/s:

  • 6-inch (15 centimeters) packs of 5/6
  • 6-inch (15 centimeters) packs of 10-14
  • 9.5 ounces (269 grams) packs of 10-12

Fulfill your dog’s need to chew with these top-notch bully sticks available on Amazon. These best buy bully sticks on Amazon offers are hand-graded and packed by weight, ensuring consistency in every pack. 

Made in registered facilities in Texas and Nebraska, the sticks use beef from North and South American regions known for their high-quality, free-range, grass-fed cattle. With no fillers, your pet gets the best of one simple ingredient: beef. 

Besides satisfying your pet’s chew urges, these sticks keep your dog busy, providing stress relief and protection for your furniture. Moreover, they promote dental health by stimulating gums and naturally flossing teeth.

What We LikedWhat We Don’t Like
High-quality, hand-graded bully sticks, perfect for small to medium dogsModerate odor may be off-putting for some pet owners
Processed and packed in the USA, using beef from renowned free-range, grass-fed cattle regionsLimited suitability for larger dogs due to the size and weight of the sticks
Single-ingredient product, ensuring your dog doesn’t consume any unnecessary fillersMay not be the ideal option for dogs with specific dietary restrictions or allergies to beef
Provides a practical solution for keeping dogs busy and reducing stress
Promotes dental health, contributing to a healthier smile for your pet

Downtown Pet Supply USA Sourced 12", 10 Pack Bully Sticks for Large Dogs, Regular - Rawhide Free Dog Chews Long Lasting and Non-Splintering - Single Ingredient, Low Odor Bully Sticks for Medium Dogs – Best Bully Sticks for Large Dogs

Brand: Downtown Pet Supply

Flavor: Beef 

Lifestage: All

Item Form: Stick

Size/s: Packs of 5, 10, 15, 30, 50 and 100

Let your dog enjoy a wholesome chew with the biggest bully sticks sourced directly from the USA. Created from free-range, grass-fed beef, these bully sticks offer a rich source of proteins, vitamins, and minerals, thanks to a single ingredient. 

The long-lasting nature of these chews keeps your dog entertained for hours and healthily fulfills their natural chewing instinct. Acting as natural dental treats, these bully sticks decrease plaque and tartar buildup, supporting healthy gums and promoting dental health. 

These low-odor, additive-free, and preservative-free treats are ideal for indoor use, prioritizing your pet’s health and comfort.

What We LikedWhat We Don’t Like
Single-ingredient product made from free-range, grass-fed beefDogs with specific dietary restrictions or allergies to beef may not be suitable for this product
Long-lasting chews that entertain your pet for extended periodsThe size of the bully sticks may not be ideal for smaller dogs
Serve as natural dental treats, promoting oral healthSome dogs may not find the taste appealing
Low odor and safe, free from additives and preservatives
Sourced from the USA, ensuring high-quality and safe products

Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks for Dogs - Premium Natural Beef Dental Bones  – Best for Small Dogs and Puppies

Amazon’s Choice in Bully Stick Dog Treats by Nature Gnaws

Brand: Nature Gnaws

Flavor: Beef

Lifestage: All

Item Form: Stick

Recommended Uses:

  • Bone health
  • Dental care

Nature Gnaws provides the best bully sticks for puppies catering to small breeds and active dogs. These extra-thin bully sticks are 100% natural, offering a savory reward chew that promotes dental health for light chewers. 

Not only are they a high-protein, grain-free treat, but also act as a natural stress reliever. Nature Gnaws is committed to providing only natural dog chews and treats as a family-owned USA company. 

They guide pet owners to choose the right chew based on their dog’s mouth width and dietary needs and also offer longer-lasting chews for puppies and aggressive chewers.

What We LikedWhat We Don’t Like
Specifically designed for small breeds, puppies, and active dogsExtra thin bully sticks might not be suitable for larger breeds or heavy chewers
High in protein and grain-free, catering to various dietary needsSome dogs may require time to get used to the taste and texture
Promote dental health and work as natural stress relieversLimited ingredient list might not cater to dogs with specific dietary requirements
Single-ingredient product, ensuring natural quality
Company provides clear guidelines on choosing the right chew

Our Bully Stick Shopping Guide

Size

When selecting bully sticks for dogs, size is a crucial factor. Choosing the right size bully stick can ensure safety and maximum enjoyment for your pet. For small dogs or puppies, smaller-sized or thinner bully sticks are generally safer and easier to chew. 

Similarly, for larger breeds, thicker or 7-inch bully sticks (17 centimeters) are often more suitable. These will last longer and withstand the aggressive chewing of a bigger dog. However, always supervise your pet during chew time to prevent choking hazards.

Odor

Odor can significantly influence your experience with bully sticks. While your dog might not mind a strong-smelling chew, it can be off-putting for humans. Manufacturers often categorize bully sticks as odor-free, low-odor, or regular. 

Bear in mind the odor-free options undergo more processing, which can somewhat reduce their natural value. For a balance between odor and natural benefits, consider low-odor options.

Sourcing

Sourcing is crucial when considering the best bully sticks for puppies and dogs. Bully sticks made from grass-fed, hormone-free, and antibiotic-free bulls are often of higher quality and more nutritious. 

Look for manufacturers who share their sourcing information transparently, demonstrating a commitment to animal welfare and quality. Ethically sourced bully sticks ensure your dog gets a safe, healthy, and environmentally conscious treat.

Some Reader Questions Answered

Are Odor-Free Bully Sticks Safe?

Yes, odor-free bully sticks are safe for dogs when appropriately manufactured. These sticks undergo an additional step during processing to reduce the natural smell. 

However, reading the best bully sticks reviews is vital to ensure that the odor removal process doesn’t involve harmful chemicals. Always choose bully sticks from reputable brands which provide complete transparency about their manufacturing process, ensuring the well-being of your furry friend.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Bully Sticks in Bulk?

If you want to buy high-quality bully sticks in bulk, the best bully sticks on Amazon is a reliable platform. Amazon offers various options from trusted brands, complete with customer reviews and ratings to help make your decision easier. 

Look for the best bully sticks with free shipping options for added value. Buying in bulk from Amazon allows you to stock up and often provides the best value for your money, especially when paired with free shipping offers.

How Much Bully Stick Should a Puppy Eat?

Choosing the best bully sticks for puppies can be a great way to satisfy their natural urge to chew, but moderation is crucial. Veterinarians usually recommend that a puppy shouldn’t consume more than one bully stick per day. 

It’s essential to remember that while puppy bully sticks are beneficial for oral health and teething, they are a treat and shouldn’t replace a balanced diet. Always supervise your puppy during chew time to prevent choking and ensure the stick is appropriately sized for your pup.

Why are Bully Sticks Bad in Some Cases for Dogs?

While bully sticks have many benefits, they can pose certain risks. Sometimes, cheap bully sticks might be sourced from low-quality raw materials or processed with harmful chemicals, presenting a health risk for your pet. 

These substandard products may also break apart into large pieces that dogs might swallow, posing a choking hazard or potential for digestive blockages. Therefore, it’s essential to choose bully sticks from reputable brands and always supervise your dog while they’re enjoying this chew treat.

What are the Benefits of Bully Sticks for Canines?

Bully sticks offer several benefits for canines. They are a natural, high-protein, and low-fat treat that can contribute to your dog’s balanced diet. One of the primary advantages of the longest-lasting bully sticks is their contribution to dental health. 

Chewing on these tough treats helps reduce plaque and tartar build-up, promoting overall oral hygiene. Additionally, bully sticks are a long-lasting treat that keeps dogs occupied, stimulating their minds and satisfying their natural urge to chew. Always choose high-quality sticks and provide them under supervision.

Why do Bully Sticks Smell?

The distinct smell of bully sticks originates from the natural material they’re made from – the pizzle or penis of a bull. As part of the preparation process, these sticks are dried or slow-roasted, which can heighten the natural odor. 

However, the best bully sticks often have a less intense smell. This reduced odor is due to extra steps in the manufacturing process to lower the scent, providing a more pleasant experience for dog owners without compromising the chew’s appeal to dogs.

How Long Do Bully Sticks Last?

The longevity of a bully stick largely depends on your dog’s chew habits and the quality of the stick. The best quality bully sticks can last from a few hours to several days. However, even the best bully sticks for aggressive chewers might last only a few hours. 

It’s crucial to monitor your dog while they’re chewing and replace the bully stick when it becomes small enough to swallow. Always choose high-quality sticks for both safety and durability.

What are Some Alternatives to Bully Sticks?

While the best bully sticks for dogs are a popular choice, there are other healthy alternatives for your pet. Antlers, sweet potato chews, and dental chews can all provide similar benefits regarding oral health and mental stimulation. 

High-quality rawhide, though it has some risks if not supervised, can also be an alternative to dog bully sticks. Another option is Himalayan yak chews, which are hard, long-lasting, and offer dental benefits. However, no matter the choice, always supervise your dog during chew time.

When Should I Take the Bully Stick Away From My Dog?

Safety should always be a priority when giving bully sticks to dogs or puppy bully sticks. Removing the bully stick from your pet when it becomes small enough to be swallowed whole is essential. 

This size will vary based on your dog’s size and breed, but generally, a good rule of thumb is to take it away once it’s small enough to fit entirely inside your dog’s mouth. This can help prevent potential choking hazards or digestive obstructions. Always supervise your dog during chew time for utmost safety.

How Often Can Dogs Have Bully Sticks?

While bully sticks for puppies and adult dogs are a fantastic treat, they should be given in moderation due to the high protein volume. Generally, one bully stick per day is recommended, although this can vary based on your dog’s size, diet, and overall health. 

It’s important to remember that bully sticks are a snack and should not replace a balanced, nutritious diet. Always consult your vet for any concerns or questions about your pet’s dietary needs.

Why You Should Trust ILV Reviews

At our platform, we pride ourselves on providing trustworthy and insightful best bully sticks reviews. Our reviews are built on comprehensive research, first-hand testing, and expert insights, ensuring we provide accurate and useful information.

We understand the relevance of transparency and accuracy and commit to unbiased evaluations. 

Our team analyzes various products considering factors like quality, safety, sourcing, and user experience. We place the welfare of your pet first, ensuring our recommendations meet the highest standards.

Trust in our expertise and dedication to bring you reliable, detailed reviews, helping you make the best choices for your furry friend’s needs.

Conclusion

In conclusion, searching for the best dog bully sticks leads us back to the top pick – Brutus & Barnaby’s Bully Sticks for Dogs. Its commitment to all-natural ingredients, low odor, and outstanding user reviews makes it stand out among competitors. 

These bully sticks provide a satisfying chew experience, contributing to oral health and offering your furry friend a nutritious treat. Remember, always prioritize quality, transparency, and your pet’s enjoyment when choosing the perfect bully stick. 

Here’s to happier, healthier chew times with your beloved canine companion.

If you enjoyed this article, why not leave us a comment below and find out if dogs can eat sweet potato treats, to add to your Brutus & Barnaby bully stick purchase?